poman wrote:
^Obviously, that question was still too difficult for most of the network. I know the network rankings are only preliminary, but I don't think I've ever seen a 36,000 point dropoff between the #7 and #8 location ranking. Talk about falling off a cliff.
I keep meaning to grade the quality of the Encore question on a scale of 1 - 10, with 1 being absolutely terrible and 10 being perfect. And this would have nothing to do with the number of players who get the question right. Just grading the quality of it. Even if the final question was, say, "Which of these songs was a top 10 hit for The Beatles?" And the answer choices were four Rolling Stones songs and "I Want To Hold Your Hand"...even though the whole world would get that question right, that would still be an absolutely terrible Encore question that I would grade as a 1. So this exercise has nothing to do with the amount of players who get the question right. Rather, it's just an evaluation of the quality of the Encore question in general.
You'd like to see buzztime get a 9 or 10 rating on this question every week. I'd even settle for a 7 or 8. But they should always strive to get something in this range.
I think I'd give this one about a 5 or a 6. It was still a minutia question (which is always bad). But what made it better was that two of the incorrect answers were albums that both hit #1, well outside of the '80s. Anyone with the slightest working knowledge of Santana could've kicked those two answers out...which leaves you with a 33% chance at getting it right.
Looking now at the chart performance of the other three albums...one peaked at #27 and went gold. The other two made very brief appearances on the charts, peaked at #95 and #102, and didn't sell many copies at all. Which is nothing more than minutia. That's a lame way to determine the outcome of a one hour game.
The rest of the game was fine. But a 5 or a 6 rating for the Encore is so-so or barely acceptable. Buzztime should strive to do better than that.
Nice summary, you're spot on with your analysis... However, talk to the hand, that's the writer of this game's opinion..
What I love is that we missed queston #5 and instead of an 80K game there isn't even a chance of a 70K when you get 10 of 11 of the questions...